I did not know Kyle. Yet, I have experienced some of what I think was troubling Kyle. Kyle was being stalked, harassed, and tormented by Stephen Schafer of New Britain, Connecticut, the same man who for months on end, has been stalking, harassing, and tormenting me. Furthermore, I believe that Kyle would still be alive today if the Police had arrested Schafer. After all, Police Officers in many towns across Massachusetts had just cause to arrest Stephen Schafer. They did not. Or would not. These towns include, but are not limited, to Swampscott, West Bridgewater, and Winthrop.
Meet Stephen Schafer. He’s in his early 30’s and lives with his mother in Connecticut. He regularly drives up to Massachusetts to stalk his Prey.

On October 25, 2020, Schafer admitted that “I sticker bombed Kyle J. Woolf’s front door with gay pride and BLM stickers.” I cannot help but wonder how many crimes were committed by Schafer that day? Stalking? Trespassing? Vandalism? Harassment? Again, it is unclear to me if Kyle reported this to the Taunton Police.
On March 7, 2021, Schafer uploaded a 4:18 video to YouTube which showed some of what he had been doing to Kyle and what he did at Kyle’s home on October 25, 2020. Despite numerous pleas from YouTube viewers that Schafer remove the video out of respect for Kyle’s family, Schafer refuses to do so.
Now, meet one of Schafer’s accomplices that day, Caroline Rentschler aka Carrie Rentler.

In Part 2 of this series, I will show evidence of how and where many Police Officers turned a blind eye to Stephen Schafer, his criminal behavior, and the criminal behavior of his accomplices. Those blind eyes served to embolden Schafer, allowing his Predatorial behavior to continue. In the meantime, I ask that you watch Schafer in action in the two videos below and share this so that others know to stay away from this dangerous Predator.
Fair warning. Sexual content and foul language. Keep your children out of earshot.
March 7, 2021
- “I sticker bombed Kyle J. Woolf’s front door with gay pride and BLM stickers.”
- https://youtu.be/wP8bb0zVRkU
- Accomplice, Caroline "Carrie" Rentschler, working with Schafer in this video.
March 17, 2021
- “Cleetus trolls DC! 11/14/20”
- https://youtu.be/LmojWPqsc1o
- Accomplices, Caroline "Carrie" Rentschler and Michael Picard, working with Schafer in this video.